The Latest News

New Ruling on Search and Seizure of Items "In Plain View"


Posted on Aug 19, 2010

Police officers can, in certain circumstances, seize evidence that is in "plain view."   This is an exception to the requirement that the police prove probable cause to a judge in advance and obtain a search warrant.  However, this exception is not allowed in every case, and must meet certain parameters  On August 4, the New Jersey Supreme Court discussed those very circumstances in the case of State v. Mann.  The justices set forth a three-part test:

1. The police officer must be lawfully in the viewing area.

2. The officer has to discover the evidence ‘inadvertently,' meaning that he did not know in advance where evidence was located nor intend beforehand to seize it.

3. The officer has probable cause to associate the item with a violation of the law.

Seizures of plain view evidence that do not mee this test are subject to suppression.  What is significant about this ruling is that recent decisions by the US Supreme Court have questioned whether the "inadvertent" requirement is necessary under the Constitution. With this ruling the court makes it clear that the three-step analysis is still required under New Jersey law.

back to top




Check out our other news articles on interesting legal developments in New Jersey, as well as a wealth of information on bankruptcy, DWI, foreclosure, and traffic court.  Should you have further questions or need additional information, please contact me to schedule an appointment.




The Law Office of Steven J. Richardson serves New Jersey, including:  Gloucester, Camden, Burlington, Salem, Cumberland and Atlantic Counties and surrounding New Jersey communities, including Woodbury, Colonial Manor, North Woodbury, Woodbury Heights, Deptford, Thorofare, Gloucester City, Washington Township, Blackwood, Brooklawn, Westville and Pitman.

Richardson Law Offices

40 Newton Avenue
Woodbury, NJ 08096
Phone: (856) 686-9910
Fax: (856) 686-9911


My Free Book

Tell Me About
Your Case

Name *

Phone *

Email *

Tell us more *


Richardson Law Offices
40 Newton Avenue
Woodbury, NJ 08096
Phone: (856) 686-9910
Fax: (856) 686-9911
Get Directions

Connect with Me